Papa’s in Milford, CT

Brick Oven, Connecticut, Milford

A friend recommended Papa’s Pizza in Milford (Devon) so I had to try it as I’m a sucker for brick oven pizza. I placed an order for pickup, one pie half sausage/bacon and one hot cherry pepper pie. They said to pick up the pie in 20min and when I got there it was ready. I was greeted warmly and was on my way home quickly. The pizza smelled so good in the car so I couldn’t wait to get home and try it. When I opened the boxes at home the pizza looked awesome. More then enough sauce and cheesy goodness. I was looking to find out if the brick oven crust held it’s own to the like of New Haven greats like Pepe’s and Sally’s. The crust held it’s own but not quite on the same level. It did have the charred edges but not the well-roasted taste of typical New Haven pizza. Don’t get me wrong the pizza was very good! In fact it will be my local spot to go to when I can’t make it to New Haven.

Tip: n/a
Oven: Brick
Wait: n/a
Atmosphere: Good Atmosphere
Pricing: $$

About Best City Pizza

Best City Pizza is dedicated to reviewing the best pizza in Connecticut and in major cities throughout the nation. Along the travels we will showcase interesting eateries and other venues that are noteworthy. If you are a pizza aficionado sign-up for our newsletter to add pizza locals to your bucket list!